Need your team to

STEP UP

Find out everything you need to know about leading and managing people in this hub.

If you are going to grow and scale your practice beyond you, then you will need to be able to lead and manage people.

This is why two of the 6 profit pillars we check in our free Growth Assessment are Pillar 3 – Team Performance – and Pillar 5 – Owner Time & Role Clarity. 

How to transform your accounting firm’s toxic culture

Written by Becky Rogers, copy and content writer for Accounting firm owners and Accounting specialists.

When your accounting firm was just you, culture wasn’t something you needed to worry about. After all, if you had a bad boss you only had yourself to blame! Then you get to 1-2 staff members and you still don’t need to worry about the culture of your firm. After all, your accounting firm is small enough that every decision and conversation goes through you. The culture of your accounting firm is dominated by your personality. But sometime after this point, culture becomes a leadership priority for you.

The problem is that many accounting firm owners don’t realise that as their accounting firm is growing they have a culture problem developing. After all, no one creates a toxic culture in their firm deliberately. A toxic culture is far more costly than most accounting firm owners realise. Research from the MIT Sloan Management Review revealed that a toxic workplace culture is the single biggest predictor of staff turnover, over ten times more influential than compensation.

Given how hard it is to recruit new team members, the last thing you want to do in your accounting firm is create something where team members don’t want to stay and flourish. This means you need to create a positive culture in your accounting firm. The culture is driven by you. I.e. what you ask for, what you ignore, how you react and what you tolerate.


Key takeaway:

  • Culture is defined by what you tolerate: A toxic atmosphere is built up over time. It stems from unaddressed bad habits and misaligned incentives.
  • Turnover risk is real: Research from MIT Sloan Management Review shows toxic culture is the single strongest predictor of employee turnover, ten times higher than compensation.
  • Accountability starts at the top: Real change requires creating psychological safety, rewriting firm core values into actionable rules, and hiring for attitude.

Understanding how a toxic culture in an accountancy firm forms

How things happen around here defines your accounting firm’s culture

Culture is not defined by any documents or posters you have with the firms’ values or plans. How your team members “walk their walk” defines your firm’s culture rather than what the firm officially says, i.e. “talks the talk”. After all values like “Integrity,” “Teamwork,” and “Client Focus” mean nothing if team members are not measured against this.

For example, consider a new team member’s first fortnight at your accounting practice. In this first fortnight, they are looking at “how things really work around here”. Think of things such as:

A diverse group of eight professionals stands in a circle in an office, stacking their hands together in the centre, smiling and showing teamwork. City skyline is visible through large windows behind them.

  • Handling deadlines: What happens when someone misses a key tax filing cutoff? Does it prompt an investigation and root cause? Or is it a “don’t do this again” type conversation that is quickly forgotten?
  • Reward systems: Who gets rewarded the most? The hyper-efficient team member who gets through a huge workload but does all their work during their working hours. Or the inefficient team member who works long hours and is often the last to leave?
  • Receiving bad news: How do you (the accounting firm owner) and managers react when a junior staff member flags up a problem? Does the messenger get shot? Are they asked to bring a solution as well as a problem? Or are they thanked for raising the problem and then invited to share their ideas on how to solve the problem?
  • Quality control: Does work below standard get reviewed properly? Is it more important to get “work out the door” rather than make sure it is correct? What happens when poor quality work gets reviewed? How are review points handled? And who adjusts the work before it goes out the door?

It doesn’t take long before your new employee is settled into your firm’s culture. Typically a toxic environment will bring a high performing employee down to the level that others are performing. Rather than a high performing new employee lifting a team up. Because your accounting firm’s culture is “the way we do things around here”, it only takes a handful of team members for a toxic culture to take root.

How much time you spend on people management defines your firm’s culture

As the owner of a growing accounting firm your time is very squeezed. It can often feel like everyone wants a piece of you. That means clients, suppliers, team members as well as family members and friends. Consequently, the basics of good people management such as monthly 1:2:1s or weekly team meetings feel like an unnecessary luxury and so don’t happen. Or if they do, they happen infrequently or become a talking shop. A way of avoiding these meetings becoming a talking shop is to adopt our Rhythm Team Meetings. Click here for the agendas for these meetings.

If you stop doing these management responsibilities, then this allows a toxic culture to thrive. After all, if you are not visibly managing people and setting expectations for how you want people to behave then you are trusting that your team will always perform well. Of course, there are rare employees who need no guidance and just get on with the work at hand with no problems. But without guidance a team’s performance often sinks to the lowest level of the team.

Many of us leave larger accounting firms or industry and decide that in your accounting firm you are not going to do the “pointless box ticking for HR stuff”. Perhaps you have the mindset that you are going to be that people manager who trusts their team to get on with stuff without micromanaging them. After all, if it’s you and just a few staff members, formal quarterly performance reviews, regular weekly operational or leadership team meetings seem like too much. Plus what is the point? After all, you are all working together so closely you know how things are going. And doesn’t your version of the big whiteboard tell everyone what needs to be done?

You’d be surprised how often accounting firm owners have this attitude in regards to managing their people. But the sooner you put in place the formal people management processes, i.e. quarterly reviews, monthly 1:2:1s, quarterly team meetings to talk about the plans for the next 90 days etc, the easier it will be to create a strong team culture going forward. Your accounting firm’s culture isn’t something you will leave to chance.

A quick and easy way to get accountability from your team is to ask each of them to send you a weekly report on what they have achieved in the week. Here’s a sample report you can use.

Your standards equal the worst behaviour you tolerate

The worst behaviour you tolerate defines your firm’s culture. Whether you like it or not! If you are too busy stuck in client work to see what is going on around you in your team, this is a fertile ground for a toxic culture to thrive. If boundaries or expectations are missed or broken your team will be watching for how you react. If you fail to visibly address the issue, then you are sending a clear signal to your team that these boundaries or expectations don’t really matter.

Not sure how healthy your firm’s culture really is? Team Performance is one of the six pillars we measure in our free Growth Assessment. It takes under 15 minutes and gives you an honest picture of where your practice is strong and where it’s quietly leaking good people.

Relevant articles

Barriers to growing your firm

If you want to really grow your business, you need to stop firefighting and start working on the business rather than in it. And to be able to do this, you need an effective team behind you. This is why two of the 6 profit pillars we check in our free Growth Assessment are Pillar 3 – Team Performance – and Pillar 5 – Owner Time & Role Clarity. 

To see whether you have a role or team performance issue or a bigger, more systematic problem, take our 10-15 min free Growth Assessment here.

Helpful resources

Get back in control of workflow by getting team members to fill in this free (unbranded) end of week report. Click here.

Not sure how to fix your team to get it to work together better? Download our team effectiveness review to pinpoint exactly what you need to do to fix it. Click here. 

Download our low-confrontational way of dealing with low performers masterclass recording. Click here.

Find an extra 8 hours to work on growing your firm. Our webinar will help you minimise interruptions and the demands on you from your staff and clients. Click here to download our webinar recording (for free)

Want to go deeper?

Get a free copy of The Accountants’ Millionaires’ Club book (you just pay for postage and packaging). 

Chapter 1 shows you how to eliminate work from your desk, freeing up an extra eight hours a week for essential strategic thinking time and headspace. (Read this if you find yourself firefighting most of the time and working very long hours)

Chapter 4 will help you if your practice is constantly running over capacity with a perpetual backlog of client work.

Chapter 6 & 7 cover how to build the right team around you and how to lead and manage your people.

Order your free copy here.

a

Your behaviour determines your accounting firm’s values

This is one of the big mistakes we see accountancy firm owners make. There’s usually a gap between what you say you want and what you actually reward. As a result your team decides what matters is your behaviour not what you actually say.

For example:

  • You say you want people to switch off in the evening, and you send emails at 10:47 PM. They wouldn’t read the “no need to reply until tomorrow”. 
  • You say you value teamwork, and the only person publicly praised each month is whoever billed most.
  • You say you want people to flag problems early, and the last time someone did you reacted badly.
  • You say you want people to take ownership, and you overrule their decisions when they’re not quite what you’d have chosen.

Identifying the warning signs of a growing toxic culture

Red warning flags with skull and crossbones line a muddy coastal path near cliffs. A sign reads Danger! Cliff edge and undercut. These flags represent the signs of a toxic culture in an accountancy firmIn accountancy practices, unlike in films toxic environments are often not easy to spot. You are unlikely to see employees resigning in a public huff. Or slammed doors or yelling. Although an accounting firm owner has been known to occasionally lose their control and shout at a team member. (Not recommended!)

Here’s how to spot problems with your accounting firm’s culture:

  • Change is hard: When you want to bring about change in your firm you’ll often think “my team will never do that” or “my team wouldn’t change”.
  • “That’s not my job”: Team members will often upwards delegate stuff to you or refuse to take on anything which isn’t within their job description.
  • If you are not in the office the productivity noticeably drops.
  • It’s always someone else’s fault: When stuff hasn’t happened, e.g. a target missed or a problem caused, team members will blame other people or things rather than take ownership for the problem. E.g. “It’s our systems” or “the client didn’t get the information to us on time”.
  • Your team doesn’t seem to care when things go wrong.
  • Clichés are forming which are isolating some team members or causing friction between team members.
  • Teams are operating in silos and not working together.
  • In team meetings, it is always you talking, and you struggle to get your team to offer ideas, solutions, or suggestions.
  • Indirect communication: You find yourself acting as the conduit for communication between team members. When they could easily talk themselves without you needing to be there.
  • Silence from high performers: Your most capable team members stop offering suggestions or improvements.
  • High employee turnover: you struggle to hold onto good team members.

A man with short brown hair, blue eyes, and a friendly smile is wearing a dark suit and light-coloured shirt, standing outdoors with a leafy green background—perfect for an Accountants' Growth Club seminar on how to grow accountancy firm success.Case study: Paul rebuilt his firm from the ground up

After Paul Wareham, founder of PSAccountants, had two key members of staff announce their pregnancies within weeks of each other, Paul realised something needed to change.

He’d been working long hours and struggling to recruit good people where their office was located. 

So, he decided to rebuild his firm from the ground up. In his growth story you’ll find out that he moved his office 40 miles away so he could walk to work.

As part of the rebuild he stopped measuring success on ‘how big the firm had got’ but how calm it was. As part of the rebuild he accepted that some of his team would not relocate or come to the new office. So where needed he made redundancies and brought in an outsourced team.

Moving the practice was a leap into the unknown, but it paid off. The firm ended its first 12 months after the move six percent up on both revenue and profit. Plus Paul is now taking more holiday than he ever has, and books the afternoons off when the Tour de France is on.


One rotten apple can poison the barrel

A wooden barrel filled with shiny red apples sits indoors; one apple in the centre is brown, shrivelled, and rotten to represent a toxic culture in an accountancy firmHaving a difficult conversation with a problem team member is something that many accounting firm owners avoid. But the problem is that this team member can easily poison other team members.

For example, one of our Accountants’ Growth Club members had a team member who they knew was a problem. They had about 8 team members at the time and were plagued by a backlog of work. As a result there never was quite the right time to have the conversation. Plus, it wasn’t just about the conversation, it was how to properly performance manage a problematic individual when they were clever enough to never quite be bad enough. After all, the mediocre performer is often the worse type of performer. Never bad enough to performance manage out, but not where you need them to be.

What they hadn’t realised was how close other team members had become to this toxic individual. When the toxic individual finally left it resulted in 2 more key team members leaving within 6 months. This left the firm very low on capacity and client service suffered as a result.

The lesson to be learnt? As soon as you see or feel that there is a problem with an individual have a conversation with them. It’s time to reset expectations on what you expect from them. Both the work they complete and their attitude at work.

The role of psychological safety in accountancy firms

Google’s Project Aristotle spent two years researching team performance. They discovered that psychological safety – the belief that one will not be punished or humiliated for speaking up with ideas, questions, concerns, or mistakes – was the single most important factor in team success. For example, it determines whether a junior accountant reports a software entry error immediately or hides it for months. Importantly, psychological safety is not about being overly soft. A team can be polite yet unsafe if people are afraid to voice difficult messages or highlight challenges or issues.

Here are three actions you can take to build psychological safety in your accounting firm:

1. Control your first response 

How to implement it: When bad news is reported, say: “Thank you for telling me early.”

Expected outcome: Encourages others to be open with you when problems arise.

2. Separate mistakes from the person’s character

How to implement it: Frame issues around processes: “This step failed; here is how we fix it.”

Expected outcome: Eliminates defensive cover-ups and reduces blame culture.

3. Lead with vulnerability

How to implement it: Openly admit when you make a mistake or lack an immediate answer.

Expected outcome: Normalises continuous learning and honest communication.

Doing these three simple things will prevent a host of issues, namely a team of people who hide things and having that how-do-we-stop-it-happening-again conversation over and over again. If you want to get your team to take initiative and speak up, download our full psychological safety checklist here (for free).

We know, you qualified as an accountant, not a people manager. That’s why at, Accountants’ Growth Club, we have programmes on leading and managing people, delivered in bite-sized chunks with weekly group calls and implementation weeks built in. Members also get a peer group of firm owners dealing with the same thing, which helps considerably when you feel like the only adult in your own building.

a

Rewriting accountancy firm core values into actionable rules

Generic core values written up rarely change how your firm works day to day. What you need to do as a people leader for your firm is build these values into the day to day actions your team makes. For example:

  • Vague Value: “We act with integrity.”
  • Actionable Rule: “We inform the client about an issue the exact same day we discover it.”
  • Vague Value: “We value efficiency.”
  • Actionable Rule: “We do not send internal emails after 6:00 PM.”

We also always tell our Accountants Growth Club members to write their value with their team, not for them. That way, everyone is bought in.

Here is how to draft values with your team:

  1. Involve everyone: Ask your staff what current practices make them proud, and what habits they would be embarrassed for a client to see.
  2. Define clear behaviours: Ensure every value describes a clear, observable action.
  3. Consistently reference them: Highlight your values during weekly updates, performance reviews, and client onboarding.


Our Accountants Growth Club member was growing quickly. They had rapidly grown to over 15 people. However, there was a culture where the team members seemed to be more concerned with getting the ‘perfect’ set of accounts and doing a great technical job, rather than being client-focused. 

To turn this situation around, the firm did a number of things:

  • Firstly, as a business, they had a team day where they defined their firm values. As part of the exercise, they agreed on a set of behavioural rules about what they would see and wouldn’t see if the value was being lived. As part of the team day, they asked clients and business owners what they really valued from their accountant.
  • They then integrated the values into the regular performance conversations. For example, one of their values was ‘deliver awesome’. So this became a standard question in their quarterly review. I.e. “What have you done as part of your role to help the firm consistently ‘deliver awesome’ to clients?”
  • Each month they had a value of the month. This value was discussed in the weekly team meetings. For example, what they could start, stop or continue to live it more consistently as a firm. 

These values and how they were applied had a significant return on their investment. Part of their values were to treat people well, as if they were a family member. As a result they were very flexible and responsive to team members’ needs. When a senior team member was approached by a client and offered a salary 3 times their current salary, they turned down the role because they didn’t want to leave the values based culture that the firm had built or the flexibility they enjoyed in their current role.


Your action plan to turn around a toxic culture

Culture is the slowest thing in your firm to change. Why? Because changing deeply ingrained behaviours takes months of consistent leadership. Here’s a turnaround you can expect if you’re taking consistent steps:

A close-up of a handwritten action plan checklist with some items ticked off in green. This represents a plan to fix a toxic culture in an accountancy firmMonth 1 (Internal Audit): Identify what behaviours you have been tolerating. Take ownership for what you need to change or do differently.

Months 2 – 3 (Direct Conversations): Hold individual one-on-one meetings. As a team revisit (or identify) your firm’s values and what you and they will see if they are demonstrating the value.

Months 4 – 5 (The Testing Phase): Team members will test how committed you are to the new ways of working and behaviour. How you react will determine the success of your culture change programme. You may find some staff choose to leave. Whilst this could create a short term capacity problem this is normally a positive sign that you are doing the right thing.

Month 6 and Beyond (Normalisation): The new culture is establishing and becoming ‘how we do things around here’

Once you establish a healthy working environment, protect it during recruitment. From that point on, hire for attitude first and skills second, because one wrong hire into a small team can undo a year of work. Technical ability can be taught to someone who wants to learn. Attitude and mindset can’t be taught.

You built your culture, which means you can rebuild it!

Transforming the culture in your accounting firm starts with you. Because culture is built through everyday habits and is the sum of what you’ve rewarded, tolerated, and modelled so far. That means you have the power to reshape it.

 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How long does it actually take to turn around a toxic culture in an accountancy firm?

Expect it to take anywhere from six to twelve months of consistent effort. Culture is built over years of unaddressed habits, so it will not vanish overnight. In the first three months, you will mostly be having one-on-one conversations and resetting expectations. Between months three and six, your team will test whether you are serious about enforcing these new standards. By month six and beyond, transparent communication and accountability start to feel like the natural way your practice operates.

A blame culture focuses on finding fault after something goes wrong, usually resulting in finger-pointing and people hiding their mistakes. Accountability, by contrast, focuses on clear expectations, open communication, and learning from errors. In an accountable culture, when a deadline slips or a tax filing contains an error, the conversation centres on fixing the issue quickly and fixing the underlying process so it does not happen again.

You start by separating their technical output from their behavioural impact. Have an honest conversation detailing the specific behaviours that need to change, such as dismissive comments or resisting team processes. Make it clear that technical performance does not grant immunity from firm values. If their behaviour fails to shift despite direct feedback, you have to decide whether keeping one profitable individual is worth losing your best junior staff and damaging firm morale.

Your immediate reaction to bad news sets the standard. When a team member brings you an error, say “thank you for bringing this to me early” before discussing the solution. Next, separate the mistake from the person by focusing on the process breakdown rather than personal failure. Finally, lead by example. Openly admit your own missteps during team meetings to show that raising errors is safe and supported.

Pushback is a normal part of the process, often happening around months three to five. Continue to hold firm on your standards and respond with clear, consistent feedback. Some employees may realise that an accountable environment does not suit their work style and will choose to move on. That is not a failure of your strategy. It is simply the natural filtering process that allows a healthy practice culture to thrive.

How effective is your current team? Ready to change the atmosphere in your firm? An effective team is essential to sustainable firm growth. This is why one of the 6 profit pillars we check in our free Growth Assessment is Profit Pillar 5 – Owner Time & Role Clarity.

To see whether your issue is just with performance or a bigger more systematic problem, take our Growth Assessment here. It takes 10-15 minutes. 

Head shot of Becky Rogers content writer for growing accounting businessesWritten by Becky Rogers. Becky has spent the last 10+ years writing copy and content for Accounting firm owners and Accounting specialists. Over the last 5 years she’s written copy for over 30 accountants’ websites. Connect with Becky on LinkedIn.